In November 1877, General George Crook went out to Dr. Victor Coffman’s farm, north of the little town of Florence, Nebraska. A big wildcat hunt was set for Tuesday, November 20, and Crook said he wanted to “look the ground over” first. He brought something with him, and he didn’t make a fuss about it: a stuffed lynx.

Crook found a large tree and set the stuffed cat on it in “a natural attitude,” which meant he posed it so it looked alive. Later the hunters came up from Omaha, Nebraska, and the general led the way.

1877 newspaper story Gen. Crook's Practical Joke, about a stuffed wildcat shown in the Omaha Herald's window after a hunt near Florence, Nebraska

“Gen. Crook’s Practical Joke.” The Dodge City Times, Dodge City, Kansas, December 15, 1877, page 6, copied from the Omaha Herald. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Trouble on a Farm Near Florence, Nebraska

Dr. Victor H. Coffman was one of the leading doctors in Omaha, Nebraska. He had been an Army surgeon in the Civil War, and he moved to Omaha in 1867. He also owned a farm north of Florence, a small town just up the Missouri River from Omaha. The Omaha Herald said the farm raised “monstrous fat hogs and nice poultry.”

Then the hogs and chickens started to disappear. The doctor decided wildcats were taking them, and his hired man shot one or two. Word got around to some of Omaha’s “prominent sportsmen and crack shots,” and they agreed to go up to the farm on Tuesday, November 20, and spend the whole day hunting wildcats.

The paper calls the animal a “wild-cat” and also a “lynx.” Back then, people often used both words for the same animal, the one we now call the bobcat, and a picture card sold for schools in 1870 calls it the “Wild Cat or Bay Lynx.”

The Hunting Party From Omaha, Nebraska

The hunting party from Omaha, Nebraska, had five men: General Crook, Major Thornburg, Al Patrick, Joseph D. Iler and L. W. Hill. The biggest name was Crook, one of the Army’s best-known generals in the West, who was in command of its Department of the Platte.

Crook also loved the outdoors. His aide, John G. Bourke, later wrote a book about him, and in it he said, “General Crook was an enthusiastic hunter and fisher.” Bourke added that Crook “kept adding to his collection of stuffed birds and eggs,” so the general knew a stuffed animal when he saw one.

Crook belonged to the Omaha Gun Club, too. Bourke named some of its “crack shots,” and the list includes Major T. T. Thornburgh (the Herald spelled it Thornburg) and men named Coffman and Patrick. Bourke said Crook took part in “all their hunts,” so these men knew each other well enough to play a trick on one another.

General George Crook in a buttoned Army coat, with a long, full beard, photographed in the 1870s

General George Crook, photographed in the 1870s. Brady-Handy Collection, Library of Congress. Click the picture to see it full size.

A Stuffed Lynx in a Tree Near Florence, Nebraska

Before the hunt near Florence, Nebraska, General Crook, Major Thornburg and Al Patrick made a plan. They wanted “to get as much fun as possible out of the hunt,” so they planned “a little joke on the other members of the party.”

First they got a stuffed lynx from Julius Meyer, an Omaha trader known for his big collection of curiosities, which are odd or interesting things people like to look at. Then, on the morning before the hunt, Crook took the lynx out to the farm and set it up in the tree.

1877 newspaper paragraph saying General Crook borrowed a stuffed lynx from Julius Meyer's collection and set it in a large tree before the hunt

The plan. The Dodge City Times, Dodge City, Kansas, December 15, 1877, page 6. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

How the Trick Worked Near Florence, Nebraska

The trick on Dr. Coffman’s farm near Florence, Nebraska, had three parts. First, General Crook led the hunters toward the tree, and along the way he told them about the tracks he had seen and other signs of wildcats.

Second, just before they got to the tree, Crook’s shoe began to bother him, so he stopped to fix it, and Thornburg and Patrick stopped with him. That way the other hunters would be sure to reach the “wildcat” first.

Third, Al Patrick had loaded the other men’s guns with blank cartridges, and a copy of the story printed in Rhode Island says he did it “slyly.” A blank has gunpowder in it but no bullet or shot, so it makes a loud bang but can’t hit anything.

The trick worked. Dr. Coffman saw the cat first and shouted, and because he wanted the first shot, he “blazed away” while the others cocked their guns, which means they got them ready to fire. They were glad “the army officers had fallen back and could not rush in and kill the game before the rest had a shot.” But “the guns didn’t hit,” and the cat in the tree never moved.

The Hired Man Had Real Buckshot

One man on the farm near Florence, Nebraska, was not part of the plan: Dr. Coffman’s hired man. “But here an incident occurred for which Gen. Crook had not prepared,” the paper said. The hired man’s gun held real buckshot, which is a load of small lead balls fired all at once.

He fired, and his buckshot hit the “carefully stuffed specimen” and knocked it down into a crotch of the tree, the spot where a big branch splits off the trunk.

1877 newspaper paragraph about the hunters firing blank cartridges and the hired man's buckshot knocking the stuffed cat into the tree

The hunt. The Dodge City Times, Dodge City, Kansas, December 15, 1877, page 6. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Al Patrick kept the joke going when he shouted, “Hold on! the animal is dead. I’ll climb up and poke him out of the crotch.” Joseph Iler was still fooled, and he warned Patrick that he would “get your head torn off,” but Patrick climbed up anyway.

The Secret Comes Out Near Florence, Nebraska

When Al Patrick brought the cat down from the tree near Florence, Nebraska, everybody could see its torn hide, with “the straw protruding” where its insides should have been. The paper said “the secret was out,” and then “Gen. Crook rolled on the ground in laughter.” Dr. Coffman, the man who had shot first, “appeared unwell.”

Everyone agreed the hoax was a success, but there was one problem for the jokers. The lynx wasn’t theirs, since it came from Julius Meyer’s collection, and now its hide was torn. The paper said the jokers had “a valuable ‘specimen’ to repair or pay for.” A specimen is an animal or plant that is kept so people can study it or look at it.

1877 newspaper paragraph saying the secret was out and General Crook rolled on the ground in laughter

The end of the hunt. The Dodge City Times, Dodge City, Kansas, December 15, 1877, page 6. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

A Wildcat in a Newspaper Window in Omaha, Nebraska

After the hunt, General Crook’s stuffed lynx ended up in a window of the Omaha Herald, a newspaper in Omaha, Nebraska. Anyone curious enough to stop could read the sign over it: “Wild-cat shot on Dr. Coffman’s farm on the occasion of the great cat hunt, Nov. 20, 1877.” The sign was a joke of its own, because as the paper tells it, the only cat anyone hit that day was the one Crook had carried there himself.

Colored bird's-eye map of Omaha, Nebraska, in 1868, with steamboats on the Missouri River in front of the town

Omaha, Nebraska, drawn as if seen from the sky in 1868, nine years before the wildcat hunt. Bird’s eye view of the city of Omaha, Nebraska, 1868, drawn by A. Ruger. Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division. Click the picture to see it full size.

The Herald’s story traveled a long way. Other papers copied it, and it turned up in Dodge City, Kansas, on December 15, in Narragansett Pier, Rhode Island, on December 22, and in Cave City, Arkansas, on January 4, 1878. That is how a joke on one Nebraska farm reached readers more than a thousand miles away.

The Wildcats at the Top of This Page

The picture at the top of this story about General Crook’s joke is not his lynx. It comes from a stereograph card, a double photo that looked 3-D through a viewer, made in Albany, New York, in 1870 and titled “Wild cat or bay lynx.” The cats on it are stuffed and posed on a log, and the back of the card says one of them “was shot in the Catskill Mountains in the winter of 1868.” The card was made “For Schools and Parlor Entertainments,” and a stamp on the back says “Price 50 Cents.” It shows the kind of lifelike pose the paper meant by “a natural attitude.”

Florence, Nebraska, stopped being a separate town on June 5, 1917, when it became part of Omaha. But in 1877 the farm north of Florence was out in the country, and a famous general went there to hide a straw-filled cat in a tree. His joke fooled the doctor, gave the hired man the only hit of the day, and left the jokers with a bill to pay. It also gave Omaha a hunting trophy that made people stop and read the sign.

Sources