In the winter of 1925, 130 men were digging iron ore in the Utica mine under Hibbing, Minnesota. Their tunnels spread under about 80 acres, the size of about 60 football fields. The farthest men were half a mile from the shaft, the deep hole that led back up to daylight. Then the air hissing out of their drills began to stink.

Nobody had made a mistake. The stink was the alarm. Up top in the engine house, men had poured two pints of a chemical called ethyl mercaptan into the pipe that fed air to the drills. The smell rode that pipe into the far corners of the mine. It was a tryout of a new kind of warning, and it worked fast. Twenty-nine minutes later, all 130 miners were out.

1925 New York Times item headlined Stench Used as Alarm to Miners in Peril, about the Utica mine at Hibbing, Minnesota, where 130 miners got out in twenty-nine minutes

“Stench Used as Alarm to Miners in Peril,” The New York Times, New York, New York, April 12, 1925, page 13. Internet Archive, public domain. Click the clipping to read it full size.

The news traveled all the way to The New York Times. Its little story that April opened with an order: “Get ’em out of the mine, and get ’em out quick!” The paper, which spelled the chemical “marcaptan,” said the dictionary gave it “a strong, repulsive, garlic odor.” Then came the punch line: “So eager were the 130 miners to escape from the smell that they all got out in the rapid time of twenty-nine minutes.”

The picture at the top of this story shows Hibbing iron miners in 1906, resting on logs by a mine shaft house before going underground. The photo doesn’t name their mine, and it was taken 19 years before the Utica test.

Why Hibbing, Minnesota, Miners Couldn’t Hear a Bell

Hibbing, Minnesota, sits on the Mesabi Range, a long ridge in the north woods packed with iron ore. In 1922 a mining journal called the Utica one of the biggest underground mines on the range. That year it sent 200,000 tons of ore up from underground.

A mine like the Utica was a maze of dark tunnels held up by wooden timbers. The worst danger was fire. A 1920 report from the U.S. Bureau of Mines warned that in timbered mines, fires spread fast and the air could carry poison smoke “to many parts of the mines in a very short time.” The Utica had a small fire of its own in 1922. It started by itself in an old, closed-off part of the mine and did little damage.

The hard part was telling everyone to leave. Mines had tried electric gongs, but the Bureau of Mines said “the sound can not be heard far,” and the wires rusted. Telephones reached only some places. Sending men to run through the tunnels was slow. At two big gold mines in California, the report said, “To warn all places in their mines by sending men would take from one to three hours.”

How a Smell Rode the Air Pipes in Hibbing, Minnesota

The Utica mine in Hibbing already had a pipe running to every spot where men worked. Its drills ran on compressed air, air squeezed tight by a big machine up top and pushed down through pipes. Wherever a man was drilling, an air pipe was right there with him.

So the smell went into the air. A trade paper, the Engineering and Mining Journal-Press, reported that “Two pints of ethyl mercaptan was introduced into the discharge air line at the engine house by means of an air lubricator.” An air lubricator is a small cup that drips oil into an air line to keep the tools running smoothly. This time it dripped stink.

The smell was so strong that it leaked out of the pipes, and the mine’s fans spread it through the tunnels too. The miners “were notified by its striking pungent smell,” the journal said. The men farthest away “walked a half mile, climbed up 300 ft. of shaft and were in the dry house twenty-nine minutes after the liquid was introduced.” A dry house was the building at the top where miners changed out of their wet, muddy work clothes. And 300 feet is the length of a football field, straight up.

1925 mining journal item headlined Stench Alarm Empties Iron Mine in Twenty-nine Minutes, about two pints of ethyl mercaptan in the air line of the Utica mine at Hibbing, Minnesota

“Stench Alarm Empties Iron Mine in Twenty-nine Minutes,” Engineering and Mining Journal-Press, February 28, 1925, page 379. Internet Archive, public domain. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Another magazine, Compressed Air Magazine, retold the journal’s report in April 1925 and said the mine used “a quart” of the chemical. Two pints make a quart, so the numbers match.

Two iron miners in an underground tunnel in Hibbing, Minnesota, in 1906, lit by candles stuck in the rock wall: one swings a sledgehammer while the other kneels and holds a steel drill, with a shovel and a pick leaning on the wall

Two iron miners at work by candlelight in a tunnel, called a drift, at the Sellers’ mine in Hibbing, Minnesota, in 1906. It is a different Hibbing mine, 19 years before the Utica test. Underwood & Underwood stereograph, Library of Congress. Click the picture to see it full size.

The Sniff Test Behind the Hibbing Alarm

The stink alarm that cleared the Utica mine in Hibbing started in Montana. The Butte & Superior Mining Co. in Butte tried putting valeric acid into the air going into its compressor. The smell reached the far ends of the mine in a few minutes. A Bureau of Mines engineer named Daniel Harrington told the bureau’s chief mining engineer, George S. Rice, and Rice had the bureau test a whole shelf of smells.

Three bureau scientists, S. H. Katz, V. C. Allison and W. L. Egy, wrote up the results in 1920. In their lab, a tester put a glass funnel over the nose and took a single sniff. Each smell got a grade on a five-step scale: “(1) Detectable, (2) faint, (3) quite noticeable, (4) strong, (5) very strong.” Then they tried the best ones in a test mine in Pennsylvania, a big metal mine in Butte, and two gold mines in Grass Valley, California.

Their chart of smells reads like a dare. Amyl acetate was “Banana oil,” “Pleasant to most persons.” Butyric acid was “Very disagreeable, like stale butter.” One chemical “resembles skunk odor.” Oil of peppermint was just “Pleasant.” The mercaptans were “Very disagreeable, similar to garlic or onions.” U.S. Army tests had shown that ethyl mercaptan’s vapor was harmless to breathe.

1920 Bureau of Mines table of smells for mine warnings, listing banana oil, stale butter, garlic or onions, skunk odor and peppermint

The smell chart, Table 2 in “Use of Stenches as a Warning in Mines,” Technical Paper 244, U.S. Bureau of Mines, 1920, page 11. Internet Archive, public domain. Click the clipping to read it full size.

A nice smell would not have done the job. The scientists explained why in one line: “When miners smell the disagreeable stenches described in this paper, they instinctively desire to obtain pure air at once.” In plain words, one whiff and you want out.

Drawing of a small glass cup and valve fitted onto a big compressed-air pipe beside a wooden door, the injector used to feed a stench into a mine's air line

The kind of injector the Bureau of Mines used to drip a stench into a mine’s compressed-air pipe. Plate I, Technical Paper 244, U.S. Bureau of Mines, 1920. Internet Archive, public domain. Click the picture to see it full size.

Minnesota’s Iron Range Used Water, Then a Stink

Before the smell, Minnesota’s Iron Range sent water. During a fire at the Belgrade mine in Biwabik, Minnesota, on February 1, 1919, men turned water into the compressed-air line. “When the miners noticed the water they ran from their working places and warned the others,” the 1920 report said.

The Bennett mine at Keewatin, a few miles west of Hibbing, put in a “stench system” by the end of 1920. The Keewatin Chronicle called ethyl mercaptan “a particularly vile smelling chemical, which has no ill effects on man.” Tests showed the odor “reaches the farthest part of the mine in less than two minutes,” the paper said, and it added, “As far as we have been able to learn, the Bennett was the first mine in the Lake Superior district to install such a warning system.” So when the Utica sent its two pints down the line in 1925, Hibbing’s neighbors had already shown the stink alarm could work.

1920 Minnesota newspaper item headlined Danger Alarm at Bennett Mine, about a stench system for warning miners of a fire

“Danger Alarm at Bennett Mine,” from the Keewatin Chronicle, printed in the Grand Rapids Herald-Review, Grand Rapids, Minnesota, December 1, 1920, page 2. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

The Same Smell Still Warns People Today

The chemical that cleared the Utica mine in Hibbing soon found a second job. Natural gas, the kind that heats many homes and fires many stoves, has no smell of its own, so a leak gives no warning. In 1930 the Evening Star of Washington, D.C., reported that experts had a fix: ethyl mercaptan, the same chemical the Utica miners smelled. “The aroma of garlic, onions, decayed cabbage, sewer gas and hydrogen sulphide have all been gathered into this new warning agent,” the paper said, and even “1 part in 15,000,000 parts of pure air stands out like a sore thumb in a crocheting contest.”

1930 newspaper item headlined Putting Odor Into Gas, about adding ethyl mercaptan to natural gas so people can smell a leak

“Putting Odor Into Gas,” Evening Star, Washington, D.C., July 27, 1930, page 89. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Today the U.S. Energy Information Administration says gas companies still add mercaptan to natural gas so people can smell a leak, and it says the smell is like rotten eggs. The Bureau of Mines kept improving stench alarms for underground mines into the 1980s. So when a whiff of gas sends someone to check the stove, it is the same message 130 iron miners got under Hibbing, Minnesota, in 1925: get out, and get out quick.

Sources