On Monday afternoon, February 2, 1920, people in Fronteras, a small town in Sonora, Mexico, about 30 miles south of Douglas, Arizona, looked up and saw an American Army airplane. It kept going south. It circled over the copper-mining town of Nacozari, then flew on. About 15 miles past Nacozari, on the ranch of an American named M. M. Sherman, it came down hard enough to damage a wing.

Two young men climbed out. Second Lieutenant Leroy M. Wolfe was the pilot. First Lieutenant George L. Usher was the observer, the second man aboard, who watched the ground. They flew for the 12th Aero Squadron from Fort Bliss in El Paso, Texas. They were supposed to be headed for Douglas. Instead they were deep inside Mexico, with an empty gas tank.

1920 Douglas, Arizona, front-page headline: Two U. S. Airmen Held at Nacozari Expected to Be Released Today, Airship Compass Went Wrong, with the first lines about Lieutenants Usher and Wolf

“Two U. S. Airmen Held at Nacozari Expected to Be Released Today,” Douglas Daily International, Douglas, Arizona, February 3, 1920, page 1. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

The next day, the Douglas Daily International’s front page said the fliers were “Expected to Be Released Today.” They weren’t. They stayed in Nacozari for more than a month, and the last part of that month was their own choice.

The photo at the top of this story shows a DeHaviland Four (DH-4) biplane of the 12th Aero Squadron over U.S. cavalry on the Mexican border patrol in 1920. It is the same squadron and the same year, but not Usher and Wolfe’s airplane.

How Two Army Fliers Got Lost on the Way to Douglas, Arizona

Usher and Wolfe had taken off from Columbus, New Mexico, on “regular border patrol duty,” headed west to Douglas. The Columbus Courier later called them “the two army aviators who entertained the camp and citizens of Columbus some thirty days ago by their air stunts.”

The trouble started with the compass. The fliers said “their compass had failed to work practically since they took the air.” Usher told the rest in a letter to a fellow officer, Lieutenant Arthur E. Easterbrook, an “ace with six German planes to his credit.” They were flying high, Usher wrote, “to avoid running into a mountain when they lost their way.” Up in the clouds, they lost “all sense of direction.”

With no compass to trust, they looked for a railroad, because tracks lead from town to town. They spotted tracks they believed were “the railroad running north to Douglas” and dropped down to follow them. That railroad “led them into Mexico.” The rough border country looked “much alike on both sides of the international line,” Usher wrote, so they didn’t see their mistake until they “knew they had not sufficient gasoline to return.” Only over Nacozari did they realize they were in Mexico.

1920 newspaper column quoting Lieutenant Usher's letter: the fliers followed a railroad into Mexico, ran short of gasoline and were first put in a jail with water on the floor

Lieutenant Usher’s letter, as printed in the Brownsville Herald, Brownsville, Texas, March 7, 1920, page 1. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

A Bed, a Wet Jail and a Hotel in Nacozari, Sonora

The fliers made their way into Nacozari, where they were held by order of Francisco M. Peraza, the presidente municipal, which is something like a mayor. The Douglas paper said “their imprisonment is merely technical and they are being treated with the greatest courtesy.” It reported that “The two aviators spent last night in the office of Francisco M. Peraza, presidente municipal of Nacozari, where a bed was provided for them.”

Usher remembered a bumpier start. He wrote that people from Nacozari and from a smaller town to the south both “claimed them as prisoners” until Manuel Mesa, an officer of the Mexican cavalry, arrived and took charge. “They were first placed in the jail at Nacozari, with three or four inches of water on the floor, but were later transferred to a hotel when the representative of a copper company offered to stand good for them.” To stand good for someone means to promise to answer for them.

After that, things got friendlier. On February 4, the paper said the fliers had “the freedom of the plaza, which means they have the privilege of going about the city unguarded.” “There are many Americans in Nacozari and they are entertaining the detained aviators,” the paper said. Its headline the day before had put it simply: the fliers “Seem to Enjoy Experience.”

1920 newspaper article headlined Aviators Still Detained at Nacozari, saying the two fliers were given the freedom of the plaza and were being entertained by Americans in town

“Aviators Still Detained at Nacozari,” Douglas Daily International, Douglas, Arizona, February 4, 1920, page 2. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Why Mexico Held Two Fliers in Nacozari

Mexico’s government took the landing at Nacozari seriously. In Mexico City, it prepared a strong protest to the United States against “the repeated landing of American aviators upon Mexican territory.” In one week, it said, four American fliers had come down south of the line. The U.S. Army had its own rule: “no aviator shall fly into Mexico under any circumstances.” Washington planned to reply that the landings had been “by accident.”

So the question of the two lieutenants went from Nacozari to Governor Adolfo de la Huerta of Sonora, then to Mexico City and Washington. On February 24, the order came: let them go.

Free to Leave Nacozari, but Not Without Their Plane

Here is the twist. The order freed the two men, but it said nothing about their airplane. Mexican officials called it “doubtless an oversight” but “refused to surrender the plane without a written order.” And Usher and Wolfe would not go home without it. “The aviators were said to be unwilling to leave Mexico without their airplane,” the Douglas paper reported.

1920 newspaper article headlined Released Fliers Await Release of Their Plane, saying the aviators were unwilling to leave Mexico without their airplane

“Released Fliers Await Release of Their Plane,” Douglas Daily International, Douglas, Arizona, February 25, 1920, page 2. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

So they waited, free men living at the Nacozari hotel, for more than a week. Finally, on March 4, the Army sent word: come home now, and leave the plane.

Back in Douglas, Arizona, “Under Escort”

On Friday, March 5, Usher and Wolfe rode the train out of Nacozari and “arrived in Douglas shortly before noon.” At 1:30 that afternoon they flew off to El Paso in two planes with two fliers from their squadron. The paper said they left Douglas “under escort,” “which is assumed to mean that they will be under arrest pending an investigation of their landing on Mexican soil.”

1920 newspaper headline: Aviators Arrive From Nacozari; Placed Under Arrest By Army

“Aviators Arrive From Nacozari; Placed Under Arrest By Army,” Douglas Daily International, Douglas, Arizona, March 5, 1920, page 2. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

That day in El Paso, Colonel Francis W. Glover said, “We shall give the young men a chance to explain their presence in Mexico before taking further action.” The next day, Army headquarters in San Antonio said the two “will be tried by court martial,” charged with “neglect of duty in flying into Mexico.” We could not find any paper that printed how the case ended. But in April, the Douglas paper reported that Flight B’s trucks were rolling through on their way to Nogales, Arizona, to a new permanent flying field. The officer in charge was Lieutenant George Usher.

A row of big two-winged Army airplanes parked nose to tail on a dry grass field near Nogales, Arizona, in 1920, with two men by the nearest plane and hills behind

12th Aero Squadron airplanes lined up at Camp Little near Nogales, Arizona, in 1920. U.S. Army Air Service photo, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Click the picture to see it full size.

The Airplane Came Home From Nacozari by Train

The airplane stayed in Mexico for “nearly two months.” At last W. W. Edwards, the American consular agent at Agua Prieta, the Mexican town across the line from Douglas, went to Nacozari to receive it. He carried “a complete list of the parts and accessories” from Captain Colgan of the squadron. Two American mechanics “formerly with the air service in France, and now employed by the Moctezuma Copper company” took the plane apart and loaded it on the train.

Then came the last surprise. “The plane will not be unloaded in Douglas, but sent on east to the factory, as all planes of that type were recently retired in favor of a more improved model.”

1920 newspaper article headlined Army Airplane Held in Mexico Will Arrive Here Tomorrow From Nacozari, saying the plane would go on to the factory

“Army Airplane Held in Mexico Will Arrive Here Tomorrow From Nacozari,” Douglas Daily International, Douglas, Arizona, March 29, 1920, page 2. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

The paper didn’t name the model. But a month earlier, it said the Army camp at Douglas was trading all eight of its DeHaviland Fours for the new Four-B. In the old ones, the pilot sat “between the engine and the gas tank, an extremely dangerous place in case of an explosion.” “The old machines will be sent to the factory to be remodeled,” the paper said. So the airplane the two fliers would not leave behind came home in pieces and kept on going.

What a Suit Cost in Douglas, Arizona, in 1920

On the same page as the February 4 story, the Levy Bros. Dry Goods Co. of Douglas advertised a suit sale. Men’s suits with “Values up to $50.00” were $39.50, and “odds and ends” were $13.50. Suits for young men “15 to 20 years” cost $16.75, “An opportunity for the young fellow to practice economy by saving 5 or 6 dollars on a suit.” A work hat cost $1.49.

1920 store ad listing men's suits on sale for $39.50, $29.50, $19.75 and $13.50, young men's suits for $16.75 and $13.50, and hats from $1.49 to $2.95

Levy Bros. Dry Goods Co. suit sale ad, Douglas Daily International, Douglas, Arizona, February 4, 1920, page 2. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Sources