On the morning of Wednesday, June 3, 1908, the telephones at police headquarters in Marion, Ohio, would not stop ringing. That morning, 3,488 calls came in. The Marion Daily Mirror said they “were concerning one subject, ‘Will the big show give a parade?'”

The big show was Buffalo Bill’s Wild West, and the answer was no. The police “hated to disappoint the anxious inquisitors at the other end of the line,” the paper said. An inquisitor is just a person who asks questions. But the officers still had to give “the answer that saddened the heart of many a poor little youth.”

1908 newspaper story headlined No Parade Was Given: Buffalo Bill Has Abandoned Street Parades, saying 3,488 calls came into the Marion police headquarters asking if the big show would give a parade

“No Parade Was Given,” The Marion Daily Mirror, Marion, Ohio, June 3, 1908, page 3. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Why Marion, Ohio, Wanted a Parade

For years, big traveling shows had marched through town on the morning they arrived. The bands played, the horses pranced, and the wagons rolled down the main street. The parade was free, and it worked like an advertisement. People who saw it wanted tickets for the afternoon show.

Marion’s store owners wanted that parade badly. The day before the show, the Mirror explained why: “they claim that it attracts the country people and consequently makes business good.” Farm families from miles around would come into town to watch, and while they were there, they would shop.

So the merchants planned to visit the show’s managers the next morning. Mayor Scherff pitched in, too. He promised “to allow the parade at the minimum license which is $40,” the lowest street fee he could charge.

The paper wasn’t hopeful. No parade had been promised on “the glaring circus bills,” the bright posters pasted up around town. Unless the merchants changed the show’s mind, it said, “it is certain that the fondest desire of the small boy will not be satisfied.”

1908 newspaper story headlined Merchants Want a Circus Parade, saying Mayor Scherff would allow Buffalo Bill's parade for the minimum license of $40

“Merchants Want a Circus Parade,” The Marion Daily Mirror, June 2, 1908, page 8. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

What Buffalo Bill Told Marion

The merchants tried. So did the mayor and the police department. They “did their best to induce Buffalo Bill to give some sort of a demonstration but all to no avail.”

William F. Cody, the old scout the whole country called Buffalo Bill, gave them a straight answer that morning. “It is absolutely against our rules; we don’t give parades anywhere and we are treating Marion just the same as any other town or city,” he said.

His show had its reasons. Most Ohio cities had strict rules about street parades, the Mirror said, and the show’s people claimed “the parade is not worth the bother it costs.”

The Show’s Side of the Story

Buffalo Bill’s Wild West gave the same answer in other towns. That August, the Colorado Springs Gazette in Colorado explained the show’s plans. The street parade had “in years past, been the usual thing” for big shows, it said, but Cody’s show had given it up.

The trains often ran late, and it was “an unnecessary hardship to compel men and horses to parade for two hours before beginning the afternoon exhibition.” With “two shows every day,” the riders and horses needed their strength for the arena.

1908 Colorado Springs Gazette story headlined Buffalo Bill Will Not Give a Street Pageant When He Visits This City, giving the show's reasons for dropping street parades

“Buffalo Bill Will Not Give a Street Pageant When He Visits This City,” Colorado Springs Gazette, Colorado Springs, Colorado, August 16, 1908, page 11. Two pieces of one story, joined. Internet Archive, public domain. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Here is the funny part. The article said “merchants in the cities visited object to parades because they interrupt business and interfere with general traffic.” When the show reached Colorado Springs in September, the Gazette even said “merchants will find that business is far better without the parade.” The merchants of Marion, Ohio, would not have agreed.

What the Kids of Marion Saw Instead

Buffalo Bill’s trains pulled into Marion between three and six o’clock in the morning. They came from Mansfield, Ohio, where the show had played the day before: two trains with 25 cars in all. The unloading was done at the Silver Street crossing. Marion’s baseball team, the Diggers, had played in Mansfield that day too, and the Mirror said their doubleheader “did not draw as large a crowd as it might have had not Buffalo Bill been in the city.”

Boys came down to the tracks to watch, and so did their fathers. The Mirror’s headline that day said “Boys and Fathers Stand in Open Mouthed Wonder.” Cossack riders, famous horsemen from the Russian Empire, stepped down from the sleeping cars “with their peculiar headgear.” Mexican riders in broad-brimmed hats and leather suits walked to the show grounds, followed by German soldiers and English lancers (soldiers on horseback who carried long spears). Then about a hundred American Indian riders climbed onto their horses and rode off to the grounds.

1908 newspaper headline The Big Show Is in Town: Boys and Fathers Stand in Open Mouthed Wonder, with a paragraph saying Colonel Cody sat on his horse with the same graceful carriage as of old

The headline and a later paragraph of “The Big Show Is in Town,” The Marion Daily Mirror, June 3, 1908, page 5. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

The show set up at the Marion fairgrounds, inside the race track. The school board had already given the kids a gift. Eight days earlier, it said Buffalo Bill’s show “will be a real education to the children and therefore there will be no school during the day after ten o’clock in the morning.” It was the last week of school anyway, mostly exams.

1908 newspaper item headlined Schools Close June 3, saying Marion's school board would end school at ten o'clock so pupils could attend Buffalo Bill's show

“Schools Close June 3,” The Marion Daily Mirror, May 26, 1908, page 5. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. Click the clipping to read it full size.

A large group of Wild West show performers, American Indian men, women and children and cowboys, posed on the platform of a wooden railroad depot in Missouri Valley, Iowa, on a 1910 postcard

“Wild West Indians and Cow Boys at Depot, Mo. Valley, Iowa,” a 1910 real photo postcard by A. N. Brown. The card doesn’t name the show, but it gives an idea of the crowd that stepped off the trains in Marion. Library of Congress. Click the picture to see it full size.

Football on Horseback

When Buffalo Bill’s Wild West came to Marion, Ohio, it had a brand new act, and the Mirror called it probably the most interesting one. It was football on horseback. The Colorado Springs Gazette explained how it worked: “five cowboys are pitted against five Indians. There is a boisterous battle to push or shove the immense pigskin through the goal posts.”

A pigskin is a football, but this one was giant. “Frequently horses are bowled over,” the Gazette said, so the riders needed real skill in the saddle just to play. In the paper’s blurry photos, the ball looks almost as tall as the men beside it.

1908 Colorado Springs Gazette paragraphs saying there would be no parade and describing the game of football on horseback, five cowboys against five Indians

From “Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show in Colorado Springs Today,” Colorado Springs Gazette, September 2, 1908, page 2. Internet Archive, public domain. Click the clipping to read it full size.

Two blurry 1908 newspaper photos of the horseback football game in Buffalo Bill's Wild West, one showing riders with a huge ball, captioned Cowboys Running Away With Ball

“Cowboys Running Away With Ball” and “A Tough Fight in the Horseback Football Game,” from the same Colorado Springs Gazette page, September 2, 1908. Internet Archive, public domain. Click the picture to see it full size.

Buffalo Bill Rode in Marion, Ohio, Like Always

Buffalo Bill was born in 1846, so he was past 60 that summer, and he still rode in every show. In Marion, the Mirror said, “He sat on his horse this afternoon with the same graceful carriage as of old.” Carriage here means the way a person holds his body. The only way to tell he was getting older, the paper said, was that his hair had turned “snow white.”

The Gazette said Cody came into the arena six times in each performance and did “his shooting act from the back of a galloping horse.” The photo at the top of this story shows him on horseback in 1907, a year before Marion, aiming a rifle at the sky beside an Indian rider.

By the Numbers

  • 3,488: phone calls to Marion police that morning, all about the parade.
  • $40: the lowest street license the mayor could charge for a parade.
  • 2 trains and 25 railroad cars brought the show to Marion.
  • 800 people and about 600 horses traveled with the Wild West, plus a herd of buffalo.
  • 10 a.m.: when Marion’s schools let out on show day.
The Marion County Court House in Marion, Ohio, in 1905: a stone building with a domed clock tower behind big shade trees, with bicycles, a horse and buggy and people on the wide street

The County Court House in Marion, Ohio, on a 1905 postcard. Downtown streets like these were where the merchants hoped to see a parade. The Rotograph Co., Library of Congress. Click the picture to see it full size.

A Busy Morning for the Marion Police

All those calls landed on a Marion police department that was short of money. The day before the show, the Mirror said Marion usually hired extra officers on show days, “but the city is too poor this year and cannot stand the extra expense.” That same morning, the city let go of Earl Isenbarg, the driver of the police patrol wagon, to save money, but only after it found him a job at the Huber shops.

“It was a fact that it didn’t seem one bit like show day,” the Mirror admitted. Many country people who came to town for the parade “returned home sadly disappointed.” Others, “more determined, went to the show this afternoon.”

Marion never got its parade. But the boys at the tracks saw the whole Wild West step off the trains at dawn, and the ones who went that afternoon saw Buffalo Bill himself, white-haired and still straight in the saddle. And somebody at police headquarters knew exactly how much one town can want a parade. They had counted: 3,488 calls.

Sources